JACKSONVILLE, N.C. - The Marine Corps has denied
clemency to a Marine who pleaded guilty in the death of an Iraqi
policeman but is suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder.The decision came despite pleas from his Navy doctor to release him because confinement is aggravating his mental condition.
Pvt.
Jonathan A. Phillips pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter in the
shooting death of the policeman in Saqlawiyah, Iraq, in 2007. Before
the shooting, Phillips was sent for psychiatric evaluations three
times. Each time, he was proclaimed fit for duty and returned to his
unit.
"I have no concerns that Pvt. Phillips is a threat to
anyone or himself, but I am concerned about the emotional impact of
continued incarceration. I suspect that prolonged incarceration will
also lead to a more protracted, complicated recovery," wrote his Navy
doctor, Lt. S.J. Stephens, in his clemency petition.
Stephens
treated Phillips, a 22-year-old infantry rifleman from Middlesex,
Massachusetts, until April when he was deployed to Guantanamo Bay.
Phillips' unit was a week away from finishing its deployment when the Jan. 20, 2007, incident occurred.
The
tour in western Iraq had been bloody and several members of the unit
were killed. One of his roommates was burned alive, according to court
testimony. Stephens said Phillips told him he didn't want to leave his
unit short-handed, so he kept coming back despite his mental problems.
According
to testimony in his Sept. 2007 hearing, Phillips had gone onto the roof
of an Iraqi police station after his unit heard an explosion.
Two
marked police vehicles pulled up in front of the station and the victim
- identified only by his first name, Monthir, to protect his family -
got out of one of the cars. Phillips shot Monthir in the chest,
according to testimony.
Phillips is scheduled to get out of
prison in September. McNeil said he will likely return to the Wounded
Warrior Battalion at Camp Lejeune so he can get a medical discharge.